JURNALTODAY.CO, NATIONAL – The Forest Area Enforcement Task Force (Satgas PKH) has once again taken action against forest areas illegally used for mining activities. The Publish What You Pay (PWYP) Indonesia Coalition emphasized that this enforcement will only be meaningful if it comprehensively addresses all parties involved, is carried out transparently and accountably, and ultimately restores the affected areas as forests rather than turning them into new mining sites.
The PWYP Indonesia Coalition cited national media reports published on 4 November 2026, stating that Satgas PKH had decided to take action against the illegal occupation and use of forest areas by companies affiliated with and/or controlled by businessman Arif Kurniawan (AK), including his network of associated companies across Indonesia.
The Attorney General’s Office confirmed that nickel is among the commodities targeted by the enforcement operation. However, Satgas PKH has yet to disclose the list of companies involved, the total area affected, or details of the violations. Such information is essential to enable public scrutiny and ensure that the enforcement genuinely covers the entire network.
AK is a businessman previously profiled in a Bloomberg investigative report entitled, “How a Reclusive Ex-Glencore Trader Became Indonesia’s Nickel King” (28 December 2025). The report described AK as one of the dominant players in Indonesia’s domestic nickel ore trade, with control over several nickel mining concessions across major production areas.
One of the companies associated with him is PT Dua Delapan Resources, a shareholder of PT Tonia Mitra Sejahtera. Since 2025, civil society organization Satya Bumi has raised concerns about this company over alleged deforestation in the protected forest of Kabaena Island, a small island where mining activities should be prohibited.
In its study entitled “Kabaena Volume II: Tracing the Origins of Environmental Destruction and the Network of Politically Exposed Persons,” Satya Bumi identified connections between AK and several politically exposed persons (PEPs), including the wife of the Governor of Southeast Sulawesi and several retired police generals. The PWYP Indonesia Coalition urges Satgas PKH to verify and publicly disclose whether these concessions, including those located on Kabaena Island, are included in the enforcement operation.
The PWYP Indonesia Coalition considers the comprehensive enforcement of illegal mining activities in forest areas an urgent priority that cannot be delayed. This is not merely a matter of combating corruption, but also an urgent necessity to halt deforestation and the destruction of local communities’ living spaces, which continue to reflect the state of extractive sector governance in Indonesia.
Aryanto Nugroho, National Coordinator of PWYP Indonesia, emphasized that the success of this enforcement must be measured against the interests of environmental protection and the use of natural resources for the greatest possible benefit and welfare of the people, rather than for the benefit of a privileged few.
“Amid the climate crisis and accelerating deforestation, nickel wealth as a critical mineral is increasingly vulnerable to elite interests. Its presence must not be used to justify new extractivist practices, including under the pretext of National Strategic Projects (PSN) or critical mineral allocations. Therefore, every act of reclaiming these areas must be absolutely oriented toward ecological restoration, not merely asset acquisition or the transfer of concession management to state-owned enterprises (SOEs),” Aryanto stressed.
The PWYP Indonesia Coalition also criticized the reclamation mechanism implemented by Satgas PKH under Presidential Regulation (Perpres) No. 5 of 2025 on Forest Area Enforcement.
In practice, the resolution of violations tends to stop at asset acquisition and state revenue collection, while ecological restoration is not made a prerequisite. This pattern was evident in previous enforcement operations, when reclaimed oil palm plantations were transferred to PT Agrinas for management.
“This mechanism opens the door for the continued use and exploitation of these areas once control has been transferred from the previous perpetrators to SOEs, without making ecological restoration a prerequisite. As a result, enforcement risks merely changing who controls the area rather than restoring the damage caused by mining activities,” Aryanto explained.
The significance of this case is also closely linked to the alleged involvement of PEPs and complex ownership structures, which Satgas PKH itself has acknowledged. Law enforcement must reach all parties involved, including beneficial owners, those who facilitate or provide protection (backers), and processing industries (smelters) that receive nickel ore from illegal mining operations. No party should benefit from the transfer of these areas at the expense of affected communities.
Meanwhile, regarding the legal process announced by the Task Force, Satgas PKH stated that it would collect administrative fines and reclaim assets based on inspection findings and applicable laws and regulations. Where indications of criminal offenses are identified, the cases will be referred to law enforcement authorities for further proceedings in accordance with applicable regulations.
Adzkia Farirahman (Azil), Researcher at PWYP Indonesia, cautioned that the imposition of administrative fines must not be driven solely by the logic of maximizing state revenue.
Referring to Government Regulation (PP) No. 45 of 2024 concerning Procedures for the Imposition of Administrative Sanctions and Procedures for the Collection of Non-Tax State Revenue (PNBP) Derived from Administrative Fines in the Forestry Sector, fines collected by Satgas PKH are calculated as PNBP from administrative fines within the relevant sector. For mining activities, for example, the revenue falls under the non-tax state revenue regime of the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources (ESDM).
“The fundamental problem is the absence of a clear link between fine revenues and the financing of environmental restoration. PNBP derived from administrative fines risks being absorbed into general state revenues because the PNBP regime does not provide a binding earmarking mechanism that ties the use of funds to specific locations and restoration plans. The government must secure these funds through the Environmental Fund Management Agency (BPDLH) to ensure that sanction revenues are genuinely allocated to rehabilitating damaged ecosystems,” Azil explained.
Azil added that the fine calculation formula also needs to be reformed to ensure that it can genuinely restore forests and the environment to their original condition. The calculation must take into account the typology and ecological value of the area, its level of vulnerability, and the total cost of restoration, in accordance with the polluter pays principle.
Based on these concerns, the PWYP Indonesia Coalition calls on:
- Satgas PKH to regularly disclose verification results, lists of companies and their beneficial owners, permits and locations, affected areas, amounts of fines imposed, as well as the status and management plans for every area reclaimed through enforcement operations.
- Satgas PKH and law enforcement authorities to ensure comprehensive law enforcement against all parties involved without exception, including business operators, beneficial owners, officials responsible for issuing permits and conducting oversight, parties providing facilitation or protection, and smelters receiving ore from illegal mining operations within the supply chain, including by tracing financial flows (follow the money).
- The Government to revise the reclamation mechanism to prevent the transfer of reclaimed areas to SOEs for renewed exploitation before binding ecological restoration obligations have been fulfilled and the results independently verified and publicly disclosed.
- The Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources and the Ministry of Forestry to impose a moratorium on new mining permits and operations in all locations undergoing enforcement proceedings until their legal status and ecological restoration obligations have been established, without exceptions under the pretext of National Strategic Projects (PSN) or critical mineral allocations.
- The Ministry of Forestry to designate reclaimed areas as forest areas subject to mandatory rehabilitation, involving affected communities in determining their legal status and restoration plans, and publicly disclosing restoration plans and progress.
- The Ministry of Finance to implement earmarking for PNBP derived from administrative forestry fines, securing these funds specifically for the rehabilitation and restoration of ecosystems in forest areas affected by illegal mining activities.
- The Government to improve the administrative fine calculation formula by taking into account the characteristics of the area, the extent of environmental damage, biodiversity value, and the total cost of ecosystem restoration, in accordance with the polluter pays principle. (**)
Sumber: Jurnaltoday