Bisnis.com, JAKARTA — Civil society groups across the Asia-Pacific region have called on governments attending COP31 in Antalya, Türkiye, to terminate agreements containing the Investor-State Dispute Settlement (ISDS) mechanism.
Joseph Purugganan of Focus on the Global South said disagreements persist over funding responsibilities, access to financing, and how global financial flows should be directed to support climate action.
“Meanwhile, fossil fuel companies, most of which originate from wealthy countries, are increasingly using ISDS mechanisms to sue governments in developing and least developed countries over efforts to phase out fossil fuels. This makes ISDS a barrier to a just transition towards renewable, non-carbon-based energy,” he said in a written statement on Thursday (12 November 2026).
He cited the 2025 UNCTAD Report, which recorded an upward trend in ISDS cases related to mineral extraction and energy supply throughout 2024. By the end of 2024, at least 249 cases were associated with the energy and mining sectors. Approximately 55% of all newly filed cases were brought against low- and middle-income countries.
Patricia Ranald, Coordinator of the Australian Fair Trade and Investment Network, said that in recent years, her organisation had observed a growing number of cases directly challenging efforts to transition away from fossil fuels.
Companies have filed lawsuits over various measures, including coal phase-outs, the rejection of permits for new coal mines or extensions of existing mining licences, windfall profit taxes in the energy sector, bans on offshore oil drilling, hydraulic fracturing regulations, and the closure of gas fields.
“ISDS poses a real threat to net-zero commitments, particularly efforts to phase out coal. One example is the case of Zeph Investments vs. Australia. The company is seeking AUD 120 billion in compensation after coal mining and energy permits in Queensland, Australia, were denied,” she said.
Meanwhile, Aryanto Nugroho, National Coordinator of Publish What You Pay (PWYP) Indonesia, said that for resource-rich countries such as Indonesia, ISDS is not merely a threat to climate policies but also a fiscal trap.
He explained that whenever governments tighten mining permits, protect forests, or restructure mineral downstreaming policies, they face the risk of billion-dollar lawsuits. These hidden liabilities are never reflected in the state budget.
“ISDS does not distinguish between the countries of origin of investors, whether from the West, China, or the region. Therefore, every new partnership in critical minerals must exclude ISDS from the outset,” he said.
Rachmi Hertanti of the Transnational Institute said that ISDS threatens public budgets and energy transition financing, as ISDS awards can reach up to 11.5% of a country’s gross domestic product (GDP). Through ISDS, companies can claim compensation from governments for losses, including projected future losses, resulting from policies to phase out fossil fuels.
According to her, fossil fuel investors have collectively sought US$433.8 billion in compensation from governments through ISDS claims. Of this amount, US$85.9 billion has already been awarded to investors.
Fossil fuel-related cases account for 36.8% of the total claimed value across all ISDS cases and 69.8% of the total compensation awarded in ISDS proceedings.
Source: Bisnis Indonesia